The Console Debate
Now that we are a few years into the current console generation, I figured it was time to take a look at where each system stands. Each has had plenty of time to get out into the stores (except the Wii), get a large catalog of games (except the PS3), and work the kinks out of the hardware (except the Xbox 360). Here at GameFury, we have had all the systems pretty much since they were released and have had some time to come to our own conclusions about each.
I will begin with the Xbox 360 since not only was it the first released, but it is also the best of the three in my opinion. The games available are not only, on average, much more impressive but there is also far more to choose from than the other consoles. Even if you tire of the new games, there is also an awesome selection of old games to download from the marketplace. There are faithful recreations of classics like Galaga or amazing remakes like Prince of Persia. If that isn’t enough, there is an expansive video store that has movies, television shows, and other videos that are ready to play after a quick download. My only gripe with the marketplace would be the breakdown of the points prices. 500 points cost $6.25 so you need to whip out a calculator to figure out exactly how much money the 240 point movie is actually going to cost you. This is easy enough to forgive, though. Add the fact that it is also a DVD player and the system can move up from being simply a game console to the core of your home entertainment center. This is, of course, if you don’t mind being without it for weeks on end from time to time while it is sent off for repair. By now, most everyone has heard of the red rings of death. Microsoft is swearing that the failure rate is less than 5% but I find that hard to accept when everyone I know has had it happen to their console and my own personal console has died twice on me. Microsoft has done an awesome job stepping it up by extending the warranty to three years and refunding repair costs to those that paid before the warranty bump, but they aren’t really doing anything but fixing their defective product that wasn’t properly tested before it’s release. A simple yet brilliant addition to the console is the Achievements system. Every game gives you the opportunity to accomplish goals and rewards you with points that are added to your overall gamer score. Before the 360 came on the scene, if you beat a game, you only have your word that you completed it. Now, with a quick look at your gamer score and achievements, you can prove that you beat a game or found every hidden item. Since your profile is visible online, everyone you play against or meet in game has access to your achievements list. Throw in online multiplayer for most games and you end up with everything you could want from a system. The online chat can also be used to talk to out of state friends, both in game and out. All in all, this is the best choice if you are a serious gamer since it is moderately priced and has the hardware power to back it up.
Next comes the Wii. Many people were afraid that it was going to be a gimmick that died quickly, but I am here to lay those fears to rest. Although I have spent more time playing games on the 360 than the other consoles, I would say that I have put more time into Wii Sports than any other individual game on any system. This brings up the fact that the Wii is the only system that comes packaged with a game. Even though it is the cheapest of the three systems, it is the only one that is ready to go right out of the box without buying more stuff. Wii Sports is very basic, but endlessly fun. It also, like many other games for the system, gets you off the couch and actually makes you get a bit of exercise. The whole system is set up to be incredibly user friendly and people who have never played games before will be ready to go in no time. There is also an impressive selection of classic games to download; probably better choices than the Xbox 360, though less in number. Many of these games require the purchase of a separate controller, but all the NES games can be played with the Wii remote. While there are already a bunch of outstanding out for the Wii made by Nintendo (Zelda, Mario Kart, and Metriod to name a few) the third part support is still a little weak, probably because they have little experience making games with such a unique control mechanism. There are a few gems out there, but there is a large number of very bad games also. While the Xbox 360 is a good choice for intense gaming action, the Wii is a better choice if you just want kick back and have fun. It’s also the best way to get a group of you non-gamer friends together because it is so easy to pick up and play. The graphics will never compare to the other systems but the best games on the system are so well done that it probably won’t even matter. The lack of a built in DVD player hurts a bit also, as does the missing online multiplayer. Since it is the lowest price system, it is easy to pick up as a secondary console and it is the perfect choice if you are new to gaming.
Finally we come to the PS3. I only call it a gaming console for the sake of uniformity. It has provided me about a much fun as a plastic spoon. I have played many games on the system and have had the desire to purchase exactly zero of them. Sony claims it is the most powerful system so I can’t understand why there are still no good exclusive games available (I haven’t played Metal Gear Solid 4 yet which is supposed to be great, but we all know what happens with over hyped games). Any games that are good on the system are also out on the Xbox 360, and many run better on the 360 than on the PS3. The few exclusive games on the system are graphically weak (like Devil May Cry 4 or Heavenly Sword) or just play like crap (like Lair or Ninja Gaiden Simga). The system has been out for nearly two damn years, the ‘good games are coming later’ excuse just isn’t going to fly anymore. There are also the stupid design decisions to consider. The controller uses an internal rechargeable battery and can only be recharged while the system is on. The cord that charges it has to be plugged into the system and is less than three feet long. This means you have to either leave the system on to charge the controller or sit right in front of your TV while playing so the cord can reach. Another dumb design flaw I had to deal with was when I switched to another TV that had a different resolution. The PS3 didn’t automatically detect the new television like the other consoles would and only showed a blank screen. After nearly accepting that it was broken, I found the solution deep in the expansive instruction manual; hold the reset button for several seconds. Even the PS2 detected the television automatically so it is stupid that the PS3 can’t. There is an endless list that contains several other little annoyances like this, like the controller turning itself off when starting some games or simple actions being buried in the confusing menu system. To add insult to injury, just thinking about touching the system seems to leave fingerprints all over it’s surface. Hint to designers: if you have to package a console with a cleaning rag, maybe you should reconsider the materials you build the console with. If you accidentally bump the controller’s power button while the system is off, it will continue to flash and search for the system for several minutes, wasting the battery. The Wii and Xbox 360 controllers will turn themselves back off if they don’t detect the system being on after only a few seconds and don’t continue to waste battery power. The amount of downloadable content is embarrassing when compared to all that the Wii and 360 have. The one big advantage is that it has a Blu-Ray Player in addition to being a DVD player, although I have yet to see a movie that looks that much better in Blu-Ray that I could justify spending $10 more on it and losing the special features that come on a DVD. I bet that if it weren’t for the Blu-Ray, the console would cost $200 less but would still be overpriced. So far, the system is a steaming pile of over-hyped monkey crap that should not be purchased by anyone….ever.
So to sum up, the Xbox 360 is probably the best all around system with an impressive amount of games and so much great content from the online marketplace. The Wii will probably have the most fun games and is great for beginners. The PS3 has basically no redeeming qualities and needs to be buried in the same cemetary as the likes of Dreamcast, Sega CD, and Turbo Graphix 16.







